Landmark Court Ruling Disrupts Car Finance Industry: What You Need to Know
The car finance sector is reeling from a landmark ruling by the Court of Appeal, which found that motor dealers offering loans to customers must disclose commissions to gain fully informed consent. This decision has profound implications for the industry, affecting lenders, brokers and car dealerships alike.
What is the court ruling on car finance?
A court ruling now requires car dealerships to disclose commissions from lenders to customers. This has led to operational disruptions and potential compensation claims costing the industry billions, impacting companies like Close Brothers and Honda Finance Europe. They must now comply with increased transparency requirements and regulatory scrutiny.
How does this affect lenders?
As a lender, this ruling means you’ll need to fully disclose any commissions paid to dealerships and gain customers’ consent before finalising finance agreements. This increases transparency but also requires updating processes and documentation to ensure compliance. There’s a risk of significant compensation claims and regulatory scrutiny, which could impact your financial stability and operations. It’s crucial to adapt quickly to avoid legal repercussions and maintain customer trust.
How does this affect car dealers?
As a car dealer, this ruling means you’ll need to disclose all commissions you receive from lenders to customers before finalising any loans. This requires a review and update of your current processes and documentation to ensure compliance with the new transparency requirements.
Operational Disruption: You might face temporary disruptions as you adjust to these new rules.
Financial Liability: There’s a potential risk of compensation claims if past deals didn’t include full disclosure.
Regulatory Scrutiny: Expect increased oversight from regulators, meaning you must stay on top of compliance to avoid penalties.
How can you remain compliant?
Here at TCG, we have developed a compliance app which will ensure your business remains compliant, completely free of charge. The app allows car dealers easy automation to stay in the clear in offering car finance, sorts all documentation and compliancy and even comes with a test drive solution.
Introducing DRIVE – the FREE smart compliant app for car dealers.
The Financial Conduct Authority is investigating discretionary commission arrangements on car loans issued between 2007 and 2021
The full story
Court Ruling: The Court of Appeal has ruled that motor dealers must disclose commissions to customers to gain fully informed consent.
Immediate Impact: Close Brothers and Honda Finance Europe have temporarily halted new finance agreements.
Financial Liability: The ruling could lead to significant compensation claims, potentially costing the industry up to £16 billion.
Regulatory Scrutiny: The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) may take this ruling into account in its ongoing investigation into motor finance discretionary commission arrangements.
Operational Disruption: Dealerships must review and update their processes to comply with the new transparency requirements.
Industry-Wide Effects: The ruling has caused significant share price drops for Close Brothers and Lloyds Banking Group, reflecting the broader impact on the motor finance sector.
Long-Term Implications: The industry must brace for increased regulatory scrutiny and potential financial liabilities.
Background & Ruling
The ruling came as a result of a case involving three customers who claimed they were unaware of the commissions paid to car dealers by lenders. The Court of Appeal sided with the consumers, declaring that such commissions are unlawful without explicit consent. This judgment has set a higher standard for transparency in the motor finance industry, far exceeding current Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regulations.
Close Brothers, one of the lenders involved in the case, has paused new motor finance lending and plans to appeal the decision to the UK Supreme Court. The firm acknowledged that while the financial impact of this specific case is manageable, the ruling could lead to significant liabilities if it sets a precedent for similar claims. Shares of Close Brothers plummeted by over 24.5% following the judgment.
Lloyds Banking Group, which owns Black Horse, the UK’s largest car finance provider, also saw its shares drop nearly 2%. Analysts estimate that the potential compensation could reach up to £16 billion, making it the most costly redress scheme since the mis-selling of payment protection insurance (PPI).
Immediate Impact on Car Dealerships
Car dealerships are facing immediate challenges due to the ruling. Honda Finance Europe, for example, has temporarily stopped payouts on finance agreements, resulting in customers being unable to collect their vehicles. This decision highlights the operational disruptions dealerships may encounter as they work to comply with the new transparency requirements.
Dealers must now fully disclose any commissions received for arranging finance deals. This change necessitates a thorough review and likely overhaul of current processes and documentation to ensure compliance with the ruling. Failure to do so could result in hefty fines and reputational damage.
Long-Term Implications for Compliance
The motor finance industry must brace for increased regulatory scrutiny and potential financial liabilities. The FCA is expected to take this ruling into account as it continues its investigation into historic mis-selling and discretionary commission arrangements. The ruling has already prompted some firms to set aside substantial sums to cover potential compensation claims.
For car dealerships, this ruling underscores the need for robust compliance frameworks. Dealers must ensure that all finance-related transactions are transparent and that customers are fully informed about any commissions involved. This approach will not only help avoid legal repercussions but also build trust with consumers.
The Court of Appeal’s decision marks a significant shift in the motor finance industry, emphasizing the importance of transparency and compliance. Car dealerships and lenders must adapt to these new requirements swiftly to mitigate potential financial and operational risks. As the industry navigates this challenging landscape, maintaining clear and honest communication with customers will be key to fostering trust and sustaining business success.